Maurice Cowling on Herbert Butterfield

← Back to Herbert Butterfield Profile
“History and the Marxian Method was the outcome of an unconscious compact which Butterfield had made with those of his pupils who were Marxists—a diplomatic attempt to keep them on the rails of orthodox historical study by widening the range of "bourgeois history". It accepted as the "clue" to a great deal of bourgeois thinking the assumption that "in the last analysis ideas...determine the course of history", and it accepted the Marxist allegation that this sort of analysis lay "in the centre of our bourgeois system". It presented Marxism as a valuable ally in the fight against Whiggery and Liberalism.”
Herbert Butterfield
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.
“In Christianity and History...[t]here were the same objections to the "stiffnecked" who "goad" man to "greater wickedness" than they would otherwise commit. There was the same objection to the "superficiality" of the "idealists" and the "spiritual impoverishment" of the "self-styled prophets" of the last generation, along with the same claim that "we create tragedy after tragedy for ourselves" if we adopt the "lazy, unexamined doctrine of man" which rests on the "recent" and "very disastrous heresy" that one should "have faith in human nature"... It was argued that the past was not a fight of "the pure and righteous" against the "diabolically wicked" but a manifestation of the fact that "human nature is imperfect generally". It was added that the historian "must join hands with the theologian" in "tearing the mask from human nature", and that the point in doing this was to show that all human actions, souls, and systems were under judgement, that they were all doomed to decay, and that humanism, liberalism, and secular idealism were as transitory as any others.”
Herbert Butterfield
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.
“He rejected authority in historical thinking, attaching supreme importance to inventiveness, paradox, and interpretative deviance. Personally, he was modest and tolerant, was free of arrogance, and disliked the entrenched prescriptions of the progressive intellect. He felt a deep and irrational regard for rakes whom he much preferred to the "virtuous and stiff-necked". In correspondence much more than in speech he was capable of inimitable flashes of brilliance.”
Herbert Butterfield
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.