Harry Blackmun on Roe v. Wade
← Back to Harry Blackmun Profile
“Should we spell out-although it would then necessarily be largely dictum-just what aspects are controllable by the State and to what extent?”
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.
“Potter [Stewart] pressed for Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton to be heard and did so in the misapprehension that they involved nothing more than an application of Younger v. Harris. How wrong we were.”
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.
“This right of privacy... is broad enough to encompass a woman's decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy....[T]he word 'person', as used in the 14th Amendment, does not include the unborn.”
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.
“When those trained in the respective disciplines of medicine, philosophy, and theology are unable to arrive at any consensus, the judiciary, at this point in the development of man’s knowledge, is not in a position to speculate as to the answer””
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.
“I am certainly not in a good position to dispute that the Court has saved the "central holding" of Roe, since to do that effectively I would have to know what the Court has saved, which in turn would require me to understand (as I do not) what the "undue burden" test means. I must confess, however, that I have always thought, and I think a lot of other people have always thought, that the arbitrary trimester framework, which the Court today discards, was quite as central to Roe as the arbitrary viability test, which the Court today retains. It seems particularly ungrateful to carve the trimester framework out of the core of Roe, since its very rigidity (in sharp contrast to the utter indeterminability of the "undue burden" test) is probably the only reason the Court is able to say, in urging stare decisis, that Roe "has in no sense proven 'unworkable,'" ante, at 855. I suppose the Court is entitled to call a "central holding" whatever it wants to call a "central holding"-which is, come to think of it, perhaps one of the difficulties with this modified version of stare decisis. I thought I might note, however, that the following portions of Roe have not been saved: Under Roe, requiring that a woman seeking an abortion be provided truthful information about abortion before giving informed written consent is unconstitutional, if the information is designed to influence her choice. Thornburgh, 476 U. S., at 759-765; Akron I, 462 U. S., at 442-445. Under the joint opinion's "undue burden" regime (as applied today, at least) such a requirement is constitutional. Ante, at 881-885. Under Roe, requiring that information be provided by a doctor, rather than by non-physician counselors, is unconstitutional. Akron I, supra, at 446-449. Under the "undue burden" regime (as applied today, at least) it is not. Ante, at 884-885. Under Roe, requiring a 24-hour waiting period between the time the woman gives her informed consent and the time of the abortion is unconstitutional. Akron I, supra, at 449451. Under the "undue burden" regime (as applied today, at least) it is not. Ante, at 885-887. Under Roe, requiring detailed reports that include demographic data about each woman who seeks an abortion and various information about each abortion is unconstitutional. Thornburgh, supra, at 765-768. Under the "undue burden" regime (as applied today, at least) it generally is not. Ante, at 900-901.”
Unsourced — Primary work/page citation not yet verified in the QuotesCosmos archive. Per our Unnamed Sources & Verification Policy, quotes without confirmed primary editions are explicitly marked Unsourced while under editorial review.